1. Rebuttal Letter 작성 정보
Rebuttal Letter(반박 레터) 샘플
Dear (editor’s name) ,
Thank you for the thoughtful and constructive feedback you provided regarding our manuscript, (paper title). We agree with you that (reason for rejection or suggestion to change paper), and we have amended this by changing the content on (p. #, line #-#), from (original content) to (revised content) , in order to better conform with the formatting and content rules of (journal name).
Additionally, we have clarified (sections or parts that you have clarified). We are certain that you will find this most recent version of our manuscript clears up the main issues you indicated in your response. However, we have not included/changed (unchanged section) as we found that (reason).
We do hope you understand our rationale for this decision.
With these changes to our final manuscript, we hereby resubmit our manuscript for a secondary evaluation. Thank you once again for your consideration of our paper.
Sincerely,
[Lead Author Name/Title]
[Corresponding Author/Titles]
[Institution/Affiliation Name]
[Institution Address]
[Your e-mail address]
[Tel: (include relevant country/area code)]
2. Cover Letter 주요 표현 모음
연구 목적 요약 설명할 때
– This study examines/presents/analyzes…
– X remains an issue for [researchers/governments/educators, etc]…
– In this study, we investigated/tested/developed….
– The purpose of this work was to present/investigate…
주요 연구 성과/결과
– Our findings confirm that…
– We have found/determined that…
– Our results suggest/establish/corroborate…
– Our findings reveal…
– Our study clarifies…
연구 결과에 대한 연관성을 강조할 때
– These findings should help/enable [doctors/engineers/educators] to…
– We believe that the findings in this paper will be of great interest/ importance to the readers of your journal.
– These findings should greatly interest your reader, as…
3. Rebuttal Letter(반박 레터) 주요 표현 모음
서두(Preface)
– Thank you for providing these insights.
– This is an interesting perspective.
– We agree with your assessment.
– You have raised an important question.
에디터/리뷰어의 의견에 동의함을 표현할 때
– We agree with you and have incorporated this suggestion throughout our paper.
– We have incorporated your comments by… (p. #, lines #-#).
– We have now [X] (p. #, lines #-#) and [Y] (p. #, lines #-#). We think these changes now better [Z]. We hope that you agree
에디터/리뷰어의 의견에 반대 의견을 표현할 때
– You have raised an important point; however, we believe that [X] would be outside the scope of our paper because…
– This is a valid assessment of…; however, we believe that [X] would be more appropriate because…
– We agree that…; however, due to [X], we believe that…
– In our revisions, we have attempted to [X] (p. #, lines #-#); however, we have retained some of our arguments because…
반박사항 반영/ 추가 설명 등 리뷰어 및 에디터의 의견을 정리할 때
– We have clarified that… means… (p. #, lines #-#) throughout the paper.
– We have revised the text (p. #, lines #-#) to reflect…
– We removed [X] (from p. #, lines #-#) and hope that the deletion clarifies the points we attempted to make.
– We have rewritten [X] (p. #, lines #-#) to be more in line with your comments. We hope that the edited section clarifies…
부가 정보 및 설명을 할 때
– We have included a new Figure # (p. #) to further illustrate…
– We have added a new Table # (p. #), which outlines…
– There are multiple reasons/approaches to…
에세이리뷰가 준비한 Rebuttal Letter 샘플과 주요 표현 모음들을 활용하여 효과적인 Rebuttal Letter를 작성하고 논문 투고에도 성공하세요!